I found it slightly problematic that rather than enjoy her discovery of the tastiness of Krispy Kreme donuts, she treated it as a cancerous thought of sorts.
- Browse more videos;
- Naughty Stories: The Crazy Dentist and Other Naughty Stories for Good Boys and Girls;
- Mindful Eating by Jan Chozen Bays | Penguin Random House Canada.
- How To Look Like An Old Man?
- Mindful Eating: A Guide to Rediscovering a Healthy and Joyful Relationship with Food.
- Mindful Eating: Buy Mindful Eating by Bays Jan Chozen at Low Price in India | cabermetimi.cf.
On first encounter, she, as she viewed it, mindlessly gorged on them, then obsessed over them while she denied herself further indulgences. Her account of making a particular candy difficult to retrieve also seemed to participate in the control found in restrictive eating and diet culture. When she claimed a healthy respect for those of us who are fat because her partner made a joke about her size, and her clothes got a little tighter, it didn't sit well with me.
This was participating in the disordered eating culture, not understanding it. She hasn't needed to experience a life in a fat body, and while I know her to be a compassionate Buddhist teacher, I would doubt she truly understands this karma. Most problematic to me was her casual mention of a Mindful Eating workshop participant.
This participant was taking the workshop in order to prepare herself for her necessarily changed eating style after her bariatric surgery. Like many physicians, Chozen Bays accepts the validity of this surgery, and gives no further comment. She, it seems to me, mindlessly accepts the cultural paradigm that fat is bad, so bad that it is ok to endorse a surgery that hinders the body's ability to function normally for the rest of a person's life. This is if it doesn't actually kill you. While there are some messages in this book I would not want to endorse, especially the controlling aspect, I do like the detailed instruction on how to eat mindfully.
For people who've been immersed in the diet culture that forces us to ignore our own signals of our bodies, this method brings you back to that body, mind, emotional, and spiritual awareness. View 1 comment. Jan 03, Kevin rated it did not like it. This book has a good short message mixed with some advice on eating that is not evidence based research.
Basically the message could have been shared in one chapter and the rest of the book is filler combined with advertising for her app. Save yourself some time and just find a well written book on mindfulness or go to google and learn about it in fifteen minutes. Aug 05, Reid rated it liked it. This book has a very good heart. I have no doubt that Bays' intention was to give us a guide to eating mindfully that would be very useful. In some ways she succeeded, but in others she was not nearly so successful.
I suppose it is useful to note that I consider myself overweight. I also think of myself as a devoted practitioner of mindfulness. I know that mindfulness can be helpful in finding my way to a healthier relationship to food.
None of this is in doubt for me. Since I require no convinci This book has a very good heart. Since I require no convincing, the key question is whether or not this book is a guide that will encourage such a new attitude toward food. The answer is a bit more ambiguous. The section of the book I found most evocative for me was the one on the seven forms of hunger.
Mindful Eating: Free Yourself from Overeating and Other Unhealthy Relationships with Food
When a desire to eat strikes, it is wonderful to contemplate what exactly in my body, mind, or heart is asking to be fed. Is it my heart? My head? My stomach? Am I really in need of food? Or am I depressed or unhappy or nervous?
Some of Bays' observations are similarly astute, particularly the practices she has developed in her mindful eating workshops or that her students came up with for themselves. However, I found it difficult to get past some of the rather broad assumptions she makes about food and our relationship to it.
A few examples: Bays draws comparisons between European and North American attitudes toward food and eating that are based on assumptions that are at best stereotypes and that she backs up with no specific research. She goes into some detail describing the way our bodies process sugar and how our increased consumption of it taxes our bodies because they are not acclimated to so much of it; this sounds like it could be true, but is it?
She cites no studies or authorities to back up this dubious claim. One more example: she uses a limited knowledge of operant conditioning to draw broad conclusions about how we come to have our relationships to food.
Shop with confidence
Yes, it sounds like common sense, but we all know how very nonsensical common sense can be sometimes, and she is probably not qualified to make these sweeping generalizations. I encourage anyone who is interested in this subject to give this book a try. But I would keep the salt shaker nearby, as you will no doubt need to take several of her assertions with a grain or two of the stuff.
Bon appetit! May 06, Cat rated it liked it Shelves: food , yoga. Jan Chozen Bays provides a solid primer for mindful eating. The seven types of hunger she outlines are a new way or I guess forgotten way, she would argue to approach eating, but for the most part not too radical.www.wellnessworldspa.com/wp-content/qihydyh/4291.php
Mindful Eating by Jan Chozen Bays | Books on Tape
We're all familiar with the concepts of comfort food and emotional eating, and sayings like, "your eyes are bigger than your stomach. I also appreciated the Jan Chozen Bays provides a solid primer for mindful eating. I also appreciated the conditional behaviors she outlines and the various inner voices - critic, perfectionist, pusher - many deal with. That said, as many have pointed out, she makes some sweeping generalizations and doesn't include enough scientific data to win over my inner skeptic.
Considering she's a physician, I would have expected more medical evidence and less "Would ya believe it? But, the book is written in a self-help style, so I suppose that's not warranted. And I'm also already totally on board with mindfulness and mindful eating so I was hoping for something more My other issue is this: In the introduction she talks about binge eating, bulimia, and anorexia as destructive food relationships.
What follows, however, largely leaves anorexia out of the discussion or treats it only as an after thought. Even the section on fasting, which is perhaps the best time to enter into that discussion, doesn't get into it. Instead, she focuses heavily on over eating and the need to curb those habits.
While many of the methods and exercises she provides seem like they would help, since her focus is so lopsided it makes me wonder whether, in her eyes, over eating is somehow more of a disorder than under eating. It's a shame for several reasons, not least of which is that I think mindfulness really could help those with anorexia as well. But the exercises she offers don't seem to deal with the particular anxieties and emotional distress specific to that disease.
I'll still recommend students give this a try, but it's disappointing knowing that many of them won't find what the book promises. Feb 28, April Gustafson rated it it was amazing. In my life-long battle of the bulge, I've come to recognize myself as a mindless eater--one of my self-mocking mantras is "Why did I eat it? There are seven. The author is very loving and compassionate in her approach, and the not-from-the-library version I'll be buying includes a CD with meditative exercises.
Mar 20, Krissy rated it liked it. I read this because Teresa suggested I pick it up. If nothing else, it has made me more aware of my eating habits. Mindfulness is awareness without judgment or criticism. Concepts I enjoyed: The 7 types of hunger: eyes, nose, mouth, stomach, mind, heart, and cell hunger.
ISBN 10: 1590305310
Inner voices: perfectionist, pusher, I read this because Teresa suggested I pick it up. Inner voices: perfectionist, pusher, and critic. Read: once. Jun 26, Annalie rated it really liked it Shelves: xxlist , non-fiction. This book definitely delivers on its promise - it certainly improved my relationship with food, probably for the rest of my life: When your perspective changes so completely I don't think it can change back again.
Highly recommended for people who would like to lose weight, as it addresses our relationship with food rather than the usual list of rules about what to eat and what not to eat that one encounters in diet books. The author is not an expert to consult for facts about the digestive system This book definitely delivers on its promise - it certainly improved my relationship with food, probably for the rest of my life: When your perspective changes so completely I don't think it can change back again. The author is not an expert to consult for facts about the digestive system and how it works.
If you paid attention in High School Science class, you'll notice a number of mistakes already! In the greater scheme of things that doesn't really matter much because eating mindfully is the important message here. Mar 04, Chelsea rated it it was amazing. Extraordinary book with fresh ideas conceived in the quiet of the author's monastic life of teaching and contemplation.